Interactive historical encyclopedia · Guerra Guasu

Acosta Ñu

The origin of Paraguay’s Children’s Day · 16 August 1869 · Cordillera campaign

Read the full booklet, with maps and infographics ›

Battle card

Battle of Acosta Ñu
Date16 August 1869
LocationAcosta Ñu (Campo Grande, Ñu Guasu), beside the Yuquyry stream, near Barrero Grande, today Eusebio Ayala
WarTriple Alliance · Cordillera campaign
DurationFrom 8:30 a.m.; five to eight hours ‡
ResultAllied victory. Caballero's rearguard is destroyed, but López escapes to the north.
ParaguayEmpire of Brazil and Argentina
CommandersGeneral Bernardino Caballero (rearguard)
Marshal Francisco Solano López, absent: on the march toward Caraguatay
Gastão de Orléans, Count of Eu (commander in chief, present on the field)
Colonel Luis María Campos (Argentine column)
Forces3,500 to 6,000 ‡: a core of 600 to 1,000 veterans, boys aged 12 to 15, old men and wounded ‡About 20,000 ‡: Brazilian 1st and 2nd Corps, a cavalry division and the Argentine column
Artillery8 to 12 old smoothbore pieces ‡Field batteries with rifled cannons; number not found in the sources consulted
WeaponsFlintlock muskets, lances and machetes; very little ammunitionRifled percussion muskets; cavalry with lance, saber and carbine
Casualties1,794 to about 2,000 dead; up to 3,300 in another version ‡
1,200 to more than 1,800 prisoners ‡
26 to 182 dead and 259 to 431 wounded ‡

‡ Figure disputed among sources. The Paraguayan figures come mainly from the postwar memoirs of General Francisco Isidoro Resquín; the allied ones, from Brazilian military histories. Not all of the allied army went into combat. Uruguay was a member of the alliance, but no Uruguayan troops are documented in this battle.

A note to the reader

Each page carries a mark that shows what kind of information you are reading.

§Documented fact. Backed by sources, cited at the end of the booklet.
†Interpretation. One reading of the facts. Other readings are possible.
‡Disputed. The sources disagree; the versions are shown.
◊Reconstruction. A plausible detail, not directly documented.

The plates in this work are contemporary illustrations, made in the manner of period engravings. They are not original documents.

The retreat

On 12 August 1869, Piribebuy, the provisional capital, fell. For López, the Azcurra line was no longer of any use.

On hearing the news, the marshal ordered Azcurra and Caacupé abandoned. The last Paraguayan army set out north, toward Caraguatay, divided into two columns. In front went López and General Francisco Isidoro Resquín. Behind, closing the march, came the column of General Bernardino Caballero.

Map of Acosta Ñu, drawn in the manner of period military maps.
‡ Disputed.The day of departure is uncertain: a report in La Nación, with the historian Fabián Chamorro, gives 13 August; other sources only say that López was no longer at Caacupé on the 15th.

Caballero's column

Pl. II. Caballero's column leaves Caacupé with its carts.
Pl. II. Caballero's column leaves Caacupé with its carts.

Caballero's column was the slowest.

It carried the artillery, the ox carts with ammunition and provisions, the wounded and the sick. With it also marched women, old people and children who followed the army in search of protection and food.

Caballero was 30 years old. He was the horseman of Tatayibá and had been a brigadier general since July 1868. On 15 August, the Count of Eu entered Caacupé with the main body of the allied army. From there he sent a cavalry division toward Barrero Grande, today Eusebio Ayala, to cut off the Paraguayan rearguard.

Glossary.Rearguard: troops covering the retreat of the main body of an army. Barrero Grande: a town in the Cordillera that now bears the name of President Eusebio Ayala.

Two unequal forces

At Acosta Ñu, two very different forces clashed.

On the Paraguayan side, Caballero's rearguard numbered between 3,500 and 6,000 people, depending on the source. It had 8 to 12 old cannons, flintlock muskets, lances and machetes, and very little ammunition.

On the other side was the Count of Eu's army: about 20,000 men, though not all of them went into combat. It was not a battle of Brazilians alone. The 1st and 2nd Corps of the imperial army fought, along with a cavalry division and the Argentine column of Colonel Luis María Campos, with rifled percussion muskets and rifled cannons.

‡ Disputed.The figure of 6,000 comes from Resquín's memoirs, which add up the dead, the prisoners and the survivors of the rearguard; that of 3,500 to 3,800, from the most cited summary. Uruguay was part of the alliance, but no Uruguayan troops are documented at Acosta Ñu.

The children of Acosta Ñu

Pl. III. Boys and veterans load their muskets in the line.
Pl. III. Boys and veterans load their muskets in the line.

There were many boys in Caballero's ranks.

By 1869 there were almost no adult men left in Paraguay. According to the historians Herib Caballero Campos and Ángel Piccinini, that year the age of recruitment was lowered to 12. Caballero Campos estimates that at Acosta Ñu there were between 800 and 1,000 veteran soldiers, and that many others were 12 to 14 years old: “not little children”, he specifies. Other sources speak of children aged 9 to 15.

A much-repeated story says the youngest were given false beards to look like adults. That detail does not appear in any known period source, and the historians consulted give it no credit. It is also said that there were women with lances at the head of groups of children: this is tradition. The Brazilian witnesses described women who fought at Piribebuy, four days earlier, not at Acosta Ñu.

◊ Reconstruction.That the youngest carried water and powder to the line is plausible, but not directly documented.
‡ Disputed.Ages: 12 to 14 according to Caballero Campos; 11 to 15 according to the historian Ana Barreto; 9 to 15 in other summaries; 6 to 8 according to the Brazilian writer Julio José Chiavenato, a figure historians question. False beards: no period source; the best-known citation is in a modern reference work, by Michael Clodfelter.

The first volley

Pl. IV. The Paraguayan line repels the crossing of the Yuquyry stream.
Pl. IV. The Paraguayan line repels the crossing of the Yuquyry stream.

On 16 August, at around 8:30 a.m., the allies caught up with Caballero at Acosta Ñu.

Acosta Ñu is an open field of about 12 km², near Barrero Grande, where the Yuquyry stream joins the Piribebuy. For the Brazilians it was the battle of Campo Grande; in Guarani it is also called Ñu Guasu, the big field.

Caballero crossed the Yuquyry and formed his line on the far bank, with eight cannons. When the allied infantry tried to cross the stream, the first Paraguayan volley drove back the attack. Then the Count of Eu brought his artillery forward, and the rifled cannons opened fire on the line.

Glossary.Ñu: field, in Guarani. Yuquyry: also spelled Yukyry or Juquery, depending on the source.

The imperial cavalry

Pl. V. The imperial cavalry crosses the stream on the flank.
Pl. V. The imperial cavalry crosses the stream on the flank.

While the artillery struck from the front, the cavalry sought the flank.

The Brazilian 4th Cavalry Brigade crossed the Yuquyry to one side and charged the Paraguayan flank. In open country, the ground favored the horsemen.

The Paraguayans did not scatter. They formed a square and met the charges with the bayonet.

Glossary.Square: an infantry formation with four faces and bayonets pointing outward, to resist cavalry.

Hour after hour

Pl. VI. Caballero's rearguard forms a square on the field of Acosta Ñu.
Pl. VI. Caballero's rearguard forms a square on the field of Acosta Ñu.

The fighting went on for hours.

The rearguard fell back, re-formed and fought again. Around midday, according to the diary of the Brazilian officer Alfredo d'Escragnolle Taunay, secretary to the Count of Eu, the allied commander himself came under Paraguayan artillery and musket fire. At another point, a Paraguayan battalion came out from the edge of the woods and routed the infantry next to Taunay, until another Brazilian battalion stopped the attack.

So the afternoon came. Caballero's line was still on the field.

‡ Disputed.Duration: more than five hours according to Resquín; six according to the Argentine historian José María Rosa; about seven according to the Paraguayan researcher Ángel Piccinini; about eight according to the most cited summary. Herib Caballero Campos says the fighting began in the morning and ended at nightfall.

The fire

Pl. VII. The dry grass burns on the field of Acosta Ñu.
Pl. VII. The dry grass burns on the field of Acosta Ñu.

During the day, the dry grass began to burn.

August is the end of winter in Paraguay, and the field was dry. Smoke covered the plain and the flames advanced with the wind. The 1872 catalog of the great Brazilian painting of the battle describes the imperial infantry charging “over the burning brush”: the fire was burning while the fighting went on.

Who set the grass alight has been debated ever since. Taunay, a witness, wrote that the Paraguayans started the fire to cover themselves with the smoke and that the flames got out of control; many wounded men died in them. In 1979, Chiavenato accused the Count of Eu of ordering the field burned with the wounded and with the mothers who were searching for their children. The Paraguayan press and school textbooks repeat that version. No document proving that order has been found, and the historian Fabián Chamorro urges taking that version “with a grain of salt”, because there are no testimonies about intentions.

‡ Disputed.Who started the fire: the Paraguayans, according to Taunay, a witness from the opposing side; the Count of Eu, according to Chiavenato, who wrote a century later. When: during the fighting, according to Taunay and the 1872 catalog; after the battle, according to tradition.

The encirclement

The final blow came from behind.

The allied 2nd Corps, with Campos's Argentine column, reached the Paraguayan rearguard and closed its line of retreat. The infantry charged with the bayonet, took the positions and captured the cannons.

Caballero escaped through the woods with a small group. According to Resquín's memoirs, the rearguard lost all its artillery, 87 carts with their oxen, weapons, ammunition and flags. When Caballero gathered his people again, he had 30 officers and 2,320 soldiers left.

‡ Disputed.The time of the encirclement is not specified in the sources consulted. Resquín's figures, written after the war, are the only ones that detail the dead, the prisoners and the survivors on the Paraguayan side.

Wounded and prisoners

The end of the fighting is the most disputed part of Acosta Ñu.

According to Resquín, more than 1,800 Paraguayans were taken prisoner; Brazilian sources speak of about 1,200. Many were wounded. The researcher Ángel Piccinini notes that some of them were treated in allied hospitals.

Paraguayan memory holds another image: children clinging to the soldiers' legs, who begged for their lives and had their throats cut. The most widespread account is Chiavenato's. The Brazilian memoirist Dionísio Cerqueira, who served in the campaign, recalled a large number of “little soldiers” covered in blood. A local tradition adds that the imperial troops stayed in the area for three days and killed whomever they found.

That there were prisoners is documented. The killing of wounded men and of men who had surrendered appears in tradition and in several authors, but not in the official reports. Its scale cannot be measured with the known documents.

‡ Disputed.Prisoners: from 1,200 to more than 1,800. Killings: asserted by Chiavenato and by tradition; absent from the reports. Four days earlier, at Piribebuy, Taunay himself had recorded prisoners whose throats were cut.

The toll

Acosta Ñu was the last great pitched battle of the war.

While the rearguard fought, López's column went on toward Caraguatay. From then on, Paraguay no longer had an army able to stop the enemy: only columns in retreat.

Pl. VIII. The field of Acosta Ñu as evening falls.
Pl. VIII. The field of Acosta Ñu as evening falls.

After Acosta Ñu

Pl. IX. The next day, the women gather up the fallen boys.
Pl. IX. The next day, the women gather up the fallen boys.

López escaped to the north. The war went on for six more months.

On 18 August, the Brazilians defeated another Paraguayan column at Caaguijurú, near Caraguatay. López marched ever farther north, with an ever smaller force.

According to local memory, women from Caraguatay carried the bodies of the boys in carts to Kurusu Dolores, in the rural district of Costa Ybaté. A wooden cross still marks the mass grave.

Bernardino Caballero survived and was president of Paraguay from 1880 to 1886. According to tradition, Emilio Aceval, then about 15 years old and president from 1898 to 1902, also came out of Acosta Ñu alive.

By Decree No. 27,484 of 19 July 1948, provisional president Juan Manuel Frutos set 16 August as Children’s Day (Día del Niño). The same decree adopted the name Acosta Ñu for the field that some memoirs called Rubio Ñu. Since 1919, Children’s Day had been celebrated on 13 May.

In 1871, the Brazilian painter Pedro Américo completed the Batalha de Campo Grande, a large canvas that glorifies the Count of Eu and the imperial army.

‡ Tradition.How many remains lie at Kurusu Dolores is not known: estimates range from dozens to hundreds. Aceval's presence at Acosta Ñu comes from later accounts.

The memory of August

Acosta Ñu did not change the outcome of the war. It changed how the war is remembered.

While the rearguard held out, López's column gained distance. That resistance did not save Paraguay, but it did save, for a few months, part of its last army.

For decades, the date was celebrated. Today historians such as Herib Caballero Campos and Amancio Ruiz Díaz call for commemoration rather than celebration. “A tragedy cannot be celebrated”, says Ruiz Díaz.

Between epic and horror lies a question: how a war came to put guns in the hands of children. And there remains a reason to return to that field every 16 August: so that the courage of those young guardians is never forgotten.

Sources

Disputed points

Six months after Acosta Ñu, on 1 March 1870, the pursuit of López ended on the banks of the Aquidabán, at Cerro Corá.

Open in the illustrated encyclopedia ›


Guerra Guasu Collection · by José Báez · Free for everyone · Home · Privacy